I decided to pester some of the group as to their views on these three distinct wine bottle enclosures to see where everyone’s favorites lie:

Trisha:

I think these are all okay options but I think synthetic corks are kinda odd. I prefer having a real one or just going for the cap. Honestly, there are some issues using corks, but I figure that’s just apart of being in the wine business. Some wines will get corked. Which ever top is more economical that’s the one I’d go for, however, synthetic corks come across as cheap to me. I do love the nostalgia of the real corks.

 

Sam:

When we look at possible wine bottle closures we need to take into account the style and typicity of the wine being made. Is this wine meant to be drunk within 1 year? 5? 10? 20+? Also, is the wine made from a specific varietal and in a particular style in which the process of slow oxidation provides additional and beneficial aromas and flavors? Or is the wine made in a reductive manner in which a screw cap provides the optimal closure to perfectly express the varietal characteristics of the wine? While understanding that research still needs to be done on real cork vs. synthetic vs. screw cap closures, I think as of now they all have their place. On a less scientific note, as romantic and enjoyable as it is to pop the cork on an old Bordeaux and see the wine stain three quarters of the way up and present it to a table in an elegant manner, the romance is replaced with efficiency and ease when quaffing a screw capped Vinho Verde on a hot summer day.

 

Melissa:

Natural Corks:
Pro: traditional and preferred especially for red wines. Awesome in the presentation when dining out and ordering a bottle.
Con: corkage can occur

Synthetic Corks:
Pro: Less expensive than regular corks
Con: Once out of the bottle it can be difficult to put back in

Screw Caps:
Pro: Super easy to open, great when traveling and for parties. White wines age at a decelerated rate and therefore last longer
Con: Cheapens the appearance of the wine package. Can be awkward or embarrassing when ordering a bottle of wine when dining.

 

Rob:

I do get a bit irked when the immediate presumption from some diners or customers is that screwcaps are an immediate suggestion of inferior quality, however it’s hard not to appreciate classic natural corks in the same way that (impractical as they may be now) film cameras never lose their beauty despite digital cameras being the standard now. Oddly, I do tend to be sensitive to sulfur issues aided by screwcap enclosures and that does happen to be something that sways my personal bias. Synthetic corks run the gamut; cheaper ones really look and feel it, but then you get something like ArdeaSeal’s version, and it has great visual appeal. I suspect that kind of aesthetically built synthetic cork will be the future (particularly from a producer’s perspective when having to deal with TCA), but well-made natural cork always looks lovely to me.